ID: 247810
Date: 2010-02-08 16:58:00
Origin: 10ALGIERS111
Source: Embassy Algiers
Classification: CONFIDENTIAL//NOFORN
Dunno:
Destination: VZCZCXYZ0000
PP RUEHWEB
DE RUEHAS #0111/01 0391658
ZNY CCCCC ZZH
P 081658Z FEB 10
FM AMEMBASSY ALGIERS
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 8404
INFO RUCNMGH/MAGHREB COLLECTIVE
RUEHHH/OPEC COLLECTIVE
RHEBAAA/DEPT OF ENERGY WASHDC
RUCPDOC/DEPT OF COMMERCE WASHDC
C O N F I D E N T I A L ALGIERS 000111*
NOFORN*
SIPDIS*
DEPT FOR NEA/MAG - NARDI*
E.O. 12958: DECL: 02/08/2020*
TAGS: PGOV, ENRG, ECON, ETRD, KCRM, PINS, AG*
SUBJECT: ALGERIA: DIRECTORS OF NATIONAL OIL COMPANY*
INVESTIGATED FOR CORRUPTION*
Classified By: Ambassador David D. Pearce. Reasons: 1.4 (b), (d)*
Summary*
-------*
1. (C/NF) Eight directors, including the CEO, of Algeria's*
national oil company Sonatrach are under investigation for*
corruption and have been fired and replaced. Industry*
insiders fear company operations will soon be affected.*
Algeria's intelligence services are leading the*
investigation. This scandal is the latest in a dramatically*
escalating series of investigations and prosecutions that we*
have seen since last year involving Algerian government*
ministries and public enterprises. Significantly, many of*
the ministries affected are headed by ministers considered*
close to Algerian President Bouteflika, including*
Energy/Mines Minister Chekib Khelil. Speculation is rife*
that political infighting between civilian and military*
leadership lies behind the case, but we have no hard*
evidence. Bouteflika's determined silence is only fueling*
the uncertainty. End summary.*
Eight Senior Officials Implicated*
---------------------------------*
2. (U) A corruption scandal has broken involving Algeria's*
largest company, the state oil and gas monopoly Sonatrach.*
The press first reported on January 14 that an examining*
magistrate ordered Sonatrach's CEO Mohamed Meziane, VP for*
pipelines Benamar Zenasni, VP for upstream activity*
Boumediene Belkacem, and five other company executives to*
answer questions concerning allegations of irregularities in*
the awarding of contracts to two consulting firms owned by*
Meziane's sons and a supplier of security equipment. They*
were questioned for twenty hours.*
3. (U) All eight Sonatrach officials were then placed under*
formal investigation ("judicial control") which requires a*
person to report periodically to police and not leave the*
country). Some were detained. Meziane himself was placed*
under judicial control; the two Sonatrach VPs were detained*
in Serkadji prison. An additional Sonatrach senior official,*
VP for commercialization Chawki Rahal, was placed under*
judicial control. Four Sonatrach directors (for social*
affairs, exploration, pipelines and transport, and*
commercialization) were placed under judicial control.*
Meziane's two sons were detained -- some stories say, for*
being major shareholders in companies to which the Sonatrach*
contracts were awarded. All efforts by defense lawyers to*
lift the detentions and judicial control have been rejected.*
Outside Sonatrach, former CEO of the bank Credit Populaire*
d'Algerie Hachemi Meghaoui and his son were ordered detained.*
4. (U) Abdelhafid Feghouli, VP for downstream operations, was*
immediately appointed acting Sonatrach CEO. The three other*
VPs under suspicion have been replaced. Energy/Mines*
Minister Dr. Chakib Khelil, whose ministry has responsibility*
for Sonatrach, claimed in a January 17 press conference that*
the investigation had caught him unawares and that all he*
knew was what had been reported in the press. He has since*
refused to discuss the allegations or take responsibility for*
the affair, saying February 2 that he had no details of the*
charges and that he would not resign. Khelil pleaded that he*
was responsible for the entire energy sector but not for*
managing Sonatrach or any of the some 50 other state energy*
companies under his ministry's purview. He assured the press*
soon after the affair broke that Sonatrach's production would*
not be affected and that the company would continue to carry*
out all projects underway. The week of January 24, the press*
reported that Sonatrach lawyers would not defend the*
suspects, since Sonatrach was a victim of the fraud they are*
suspected of committing.*
Foreign Producers Worried*
-------------------------*
5. (C/NF) Ambassador on January 27 met XXXXXXXXXXXX*
Meziane. XXXXXXXXXXXX sources tell him the issue under*
investigation is Sonatrach's granting of sole-source*
contracts. Sonatrach's regulations specify strict conditions*
for this type of contract ("procedure R-115"). Only CEO*
Meziane would have had authority to authorize and approve*
them.*
6. (C/NF) XXXXXXXXXXXX had heard that 1,600 such contracts were*
under investigation. Some of these contracts reportedly went*
through Meziane's sons. A few years earlier, Sonatrach had*
pressed Anadarko to enter into one such contract jointly with*
the U.S.-Algerian joint venture BRC (Brown and Root-Condor)*
to develop the el-Merk oilfield. XXXXXXXXXXXX, the contract was never*
carried out, BRC was liquidated, and Sonatrach in 2008*
awarded the el-Merk contract to Anadarko. XXXXXXXXXXXX stated that*
this contract was not/not one of those under investigation.*
(Comment: BRC, nonetheless, figures in the list of ongoing*
investigations cited in the press. End comment)*
Date: 2010-02-08 16:58:00
Origin: 10ALGIERS111
Source: Embassy Algiers
Classification: CONFIDENTIAL//NOFORN
Dunno:
Destination: VZCZCXYZ0000
PP RUEHWEB
DE RUEHAS #0111/01 0391658
ZNY CCCCC ZZH
P 081658Z FEB 10
FM AMEMBASSY ALGIERS
TO RUEHC/SECSTATE WASHDC PRIORITY 8404
INFO RUCNMGH/MAGHREB COLLECTIVE
RUEHHH/OPEC COLLECTIVE
RHEBAAA/DEPT OF ENERGY WASHDC
RUCPDOC/DEPT OF COMMERCE WASHDC
C O N F I D E N T I A L ALGIERS 000111*
NOFORN*
SIPDIS*
DEPT FOR NEA/MAG - NARDI*
E.O. 12958: DECL: 02/08/2020*
TAGS: PGOV, ENRG, ECON, ETRD, KCRM, PINS, AG*
SUBJECT: ALGERIA: DIRECTORS OF NATIONAL OIL COMPANY*
INVESTIGATED FOR CORRUPTION*
Classified By: Ambassador David D. Pearce. Reasons: 1.4 (b), (d)*
Summary*
-------*
1. (C/NF) Eight directors, including the CEO, of Algeria's*
national oil company Sonatrach are under investigation for*
corruption and have been fired and replaced. Industry*
insiders fear company operations will soon be affected.*
Algeria's intelligence services are leading the*
investigation. This scandal is the latest in a dramatically*
escalating series of investigations and prosecutions that we*
have seen since last year involving Algerian government*
ministries and public enterprises. Significantly, many of*
the ministries affected are headed by ministers considered*
close to Algerian President Bouteflika, including*
Energy/Mines Minister Chekib Khelil. Speculation is rife*
that political infighting between civilian and military*
leadership lies behind the case, but we have no hard*
evidence. Bouteflika's determined silence is only fueling*
the uncertainty. End summary.*
Eight Senior Officials Implicated*
---------------------------------*
2. (U) A corruption scandal has broken involving Algeria's*
largest company, the state oil and gas monopoly Sonatrach.*
The press first reported on January 14 that an examining*
magistrate ordered Sonatrach's CEO Mohamed Meziane, VP for*
pipelines Benamar Zenasni, VP for upstream activity*
Boumediene Belkacem, and five other company executives to*
answer questions concerning allegations of irregularities in*
the awarding of contracts to two consulting firms owned by*
Meziane's sons and a supplier of security equipment. They*
were questioned for twenty hours.*
3. (U) All eight Sonatrach officials were then placed under*
formal investigation ("judicial control") which requires a*
person to report periodically to police and not leave the*
country). Some were detained. Meziane himself was placed*
under judicial control; the two Sonatrach VPs were detained*
in Serkadji prison. An additional Sonatrach senior official,*
VP for commercialization Chawki Rahal, was placed under*
judicial control. Four Sonatrach directors (for social*
affairs, exploration, pipelines and transport, and*
commercialization) were placed under judicial control.*
Meziane's two sons were detained -- some stories say, for*
being major shareholders in companies to which the Sonatrach*
contracts were awarded. All efforts by defense lawyers to*
lift the detentions and judicial control have been rejected.*
Outside Sonatrach, former CEO of the bank Credit Populaire*
d'Algerie Hachemi Meghaoui and his son were ordered detained.*
4. (U) Abdelhafid Feghouli, VP for downstream operations, was*
immediately appointed acting Sonatrach CEO. The three other*
VPs under suspicion have been replaced. Energy/Mines*
Minister Dr. Chakib Khelil, whose ministry has responsibility*
for Sonatrach, claimed in a January 17 press conference that*
the investigation had caught him unawares and that all he*
knew was what had been reported in the press. He has since*
refused to discuss the allegations or take responsibility for*
the affair, saying February 2 that he had no details of the*
charges and that he would not resign. Khelil pleaded that he*
was responsible for the entire energy sector but not for*
managing Sonatrach or any of the some 50 other state energy*
companies under his ministry's purview. He assured the press*
soon after the affair broke that Sonatrach's production would*
not be affected and that the company would continue to carry*
out all projects underway. The week of January 24, the press*
reported that Sonatrach lawyers would not defend the*
suspects, since Sonatrach was a victim of the fraud they are*
suspected of committing.*
Foreign Producers Worried*
-------------------------*
5. (C/NF) Ambassador on January 27 met XXXXXXXXXXXX*
Meziane. XXXXXXXXXXXX sources tell him the issue under*
investigation is Sonatrach's granting of sole-source*
contracts. Sonatrach's regulations specify strict conditions*
for this type of contract ("procedure R-115"). Only CEO*
Meziane would have had authority to authorize and approve*
them.*
6. (C/NF) XXXXXXXXXXXX had heard that 1,600 such contracts were*
under investigation. Some of these contracts reportedly went*
through Meziane's sons. A few years earlier, Sonatrach had*
pressed Anadarko to enter into one such contract jointly with*
the U.S.-Algerian joint venture BRC (Brown and Root-Condor)*
to develop the el-Merk oilfield. XXXXXXXXXXXX, the contract was never*
carried out, BRC was liquidated, and Sonatrach in 2008*
awarded the el-Merk contract to Anadarko. XXXXXXXXXXXX stated that*
this contract was not/not one of those under investigation.*
(Comment: BRC, nonetheless, figures in the list of ongoing*
investigations cited in the press. End comment)*
Commentaire